Crimes, Harms, and Wrongs: On the Principles of Criminalisation

When should we make use of the criminal law? Crimes, Harms, and Wrongs offers a philosophical analysis of the nature and ethical limits of criminalisation. The authors explore the scope of harm-based prohibitions, proscriptions of offensive behaviour, and paternalistic prohibitions aimed at preventing self-harm, developing guiding principles for these various grounds of state prohibition. Both authors have written extensively in the field. They have produced an integrated, accessible, philosophically-sophisticated account that will be of great interest to legal academics, philosophers, and advanced students alike. this elegant, closely argued and convincing book is of great value and can be expected to be of lasting influence. James Chalmers Crimes, Harms, and Wrongs . . . is a welcome addition to this field, and should clarify the readers thinking on a breathtakingly broad range of issues. . . . This is an important book, and [its] consideration of not only Anglo-American theory and law, but also German legal doctrines and writings on criminalisation, should ensure that this debate reaches new heights in the future. Findlay Stark the result of [the authors] many decades of thought and writing on this fundamental subject is an integrated, accessible, philosophically sophisticated discussion of this subject. Justice Gilles Renaud A.P. Simester and Andreas von Hirsch present an informed and systematic account of the principles that, in their view, should structure decisions about what to criminalize, and when. Vincent Chiao an outstanding work, original in many respects and meticulous in its arguments. It represents the greatest advance on this subject since Feinbergs four volumes . . . an outstanding contribution to the re-invigorated criminalization debate. Andrew Ashworth important, original, interesting, and often ingenious. Unlike some recent competitive books it has the virtue of making sound arguments. And like everything else the authors have written, it is a joy to read This is an absolutely wonderful book. Douglas Husak See more