The Importance of Being Poirot

Written by the renowned British historian who has been described as both utterly thorough and humanely delicate, Jeremy Black offers a guided tour through the mind of Agatha Christie and life during the Great World Wars. His incomparable treatment of literary craft developing alongside global military engagement nearly overshadows the natural draw of the crime drama that is the subject of his book. Indeed, the prurience and sensationalism of crime is not as exciting as Blacks aptitude for drawing the reality from the fiction (and periphery sources), giving Christie a much louder voice than she might ever have dreamed. If Christie is also moralist and mirror to her times, Black here plays his part as the detective and reveals layers of previously unmined truths in her stories.

Hercule Poirot as a character is masterfully imagined, but Black shows us how he is inseparable from Christies turbulent and changing world. He also illuminates significant social commentary in Christies fiction, and in so doing Black often uses his authority to vindicate Christies work from hastily, at times stupidly, applied labels and interpretations. He is especially magnificent in his chapters, Xenophobia and The Sixties. Black nevertheless gives due recognition to Christies critics when they have something relevant and reasonable to say, and hence the reader finds yet another service in Blacks comprehensive review of the reviewers over the expanse of Christies writing career.

For all this, Black proves himself to be a worthy history-teller because he can aptly detect the meaning of stories that seeks to answer the past and guide the present. His erudition runs much deeper than his ability to navigate the stores of resources available on the subject, and the reader gets a glimpse of this early on when in the introduction he proffers his own defense for writing about the importance of a Hercule Poirot. Black writes, the notion of crime had a moral component from the outset, and notably so in terms of the struggle between Good and Evil, and in the detection of the latter. Indeed, it is this detection that is the basis of the most powerful strand of detection story, because Evil disguises its purposes. It has to do so in a world and humanity made fundamentally benign and moral by God. The Golden Age of detective novels represents much more than a triumph of a literary genre. It is in its own right a story of how the challenge to address the problem of evil was accepted. Its convergence with the plot-rich narrative of the twentieth century in the modern age renders Blacks account a thrilling masterpiece, seducing historians to read fiction and crime junkies to read more history.
  See more